ECCAY RESOURCES
Exercise nr. 31
EMPATHIC LISTENING
|
Minimum number of participants |
Average time length | Individual setting |
Group setting | Special Equipment | Unit | Online | Challenges/ competition |
| 2 | 1,5 hours | no | yes | no | 2,3,4,5 | yes (but limited) | no |
This exercise for pairs and groups helps to understand the importance of empathic listening and learn how to become an empathic listener.
Empathic listening is an important valuable personal growth and relational skills.
Hearing (like taste, touch, vision) is one of our natural senses. We always hear something, it does not necessarily require special attention. Listening, however, requires focus and attention. Listening is intentional (indeed, like telling) and to a single ‘message’ (e.g. a story, music). People are born with hearing but listening is developed by learning in (social) contexts.
Practising empathic listening means that you
● Allow the other person to lead the conversation and determine the topic discussed.
● Remain utterly attentive to what the other person is saying.
● Avoid interrupting, even when you have something important to add.
● Ask open-ended questions that invite more from the speaker
● Avoid coming to premature conclusions or offering solutions.
● Reflect to the speaker what you heard them say.
You can practice your own professional empathic listening skills with different exercises, but in this exercise we focus on one in which you work with your clients/users on increasing their empathic listening skills.
Aim / Benefits
Empathic listening creates a safe space for conflict resolution and problem-solving, it builds respect, trust, and mutual understanding, relieves tensions and discord and encourages deeper sharing of feelings and information
UNIT(s) related
It is also relevant to underpin the scaffolding and proximal development, and build relationships, which are the topic of Unit 3. In a similar matter is it also relevant for Unit 4, the SFA approach requires good empathic listening skills on the side of the professional and also for their clients/users when working in groups.
For Unit 5 is it relevant for group reflective practises, as without the capacity of a group to listen actively and empathically to others members, the reflection might not be so effective.
How to do the exercise
(MANDATORY to explain how to prepare and introduce the exercise to the participant)
Before starting the exercise, briefly explain what empathetic listening means.
The actual exercise, emphasises 3 key ingredients:
- Pauses;
- Verbal paraphrasing;
- Non-verbal paraphrasing.
InUse open-ended questions ( the questions in Units 2 can be helpful in this case, too) about his/her gestures. For instance; “While you were talking you shook your head; What does it mean?”; “You moved your hand while you were talking about this topic: What do you think this gesture communicates to you?”...
● Allow for silences: resist the urge to fill the silence.
● And above all: Keep calm.
Then explain how the exercise will actually be done, i.e, explain that it consists of practising three aspects of empathic listening, and that the exercise is repeated 2 or 3 times (if deemed relevant) so that all participants experience the 3 roles present in the exercise:
- Speaker
- Listener
- Observer. The role is to observe the dialogue between the speaker and interviewer, and provide observer constructive feedback.
As a quick note, the exercise can be done without the observer role, due to time constraints, however the role adds on valuable information and being an observer allows one to look outward-in into the listening process. If the professional works with a pair, he/she should take on the observer role.
Step 2
In the first part of the actual exercise the participants are introduced to the topic of paraphrasing.
The professional explains to the participants the term paraphrasing and what it means, i.e. rewording of another person’s thoughts and/or feelings. It gives the message to the Speaker that the Listener is listening, is interested, is caring about what the Speaker is saying and is trying to understand what is important to the Speaker.
The participants also receive information on what they are expected to paraphrase. The professional explains that they should paraphrase the content, the emotion (in particular stemming from the Speakers, voice and body language) or both. The Listener needs to be aware that a good paraphrase gets to the core of what the Speaker was saying, and should be shorter than the original words. It should always begin with “you” (not “I”). In essence it aims to capture the Speakers’ intention, and not repeat the Speakers words exactly, but at the same time it should not introduce new concepts or thoughts.
The professional then provides examples. However he/she can decide to have a short paraphrasing practice in the case he/she considers that this would enhance the Empathic Listening exercise, and that due to the characteristics of their participants this would enhance the effectiveness of the full Empathic Listening exercise.
If the professional decides to do a short practice, these are the steps:
- Create pairs
- Ask the participants to speak on a topic that is important in their lives for about 30-60 seconds maximum.
- When the Speaker finishes the Listener paraphrases the content, remembering the rules for paraphrasing.
Step 3
After the professional has explained (and in case of needs practised) the paraphrasing, the third aspect of the exercise is introduced, which is related to non-verbal paraphrasing and non-verbal communication.
The professional reviews with the participants the strategies for reflecting feelings described in Step 2.
Apart from these, the professional can also decide to provide examples or images and ask the participants to analyse whether there is adequate non-verbal paraphrasing.
The professional can also decide to do a short practice.
In this case a good option would be to use the same pairs as in the exercise of Step 2, but turn the roles around (Speaker is now Listener and vice-versa) and then ask the Listener to practice non-verbal paraphrasing.
If the professional decides to do a short practice, these are the steps:
- Create pairs
- Ask the participants to speak on a topic that is important in their lives for about 30-60 seconds maximum.
- When the Speaker finishes the Listener using non-verbal paraphrasing the content.
Step 4
After these steps, a full-fledged Empathic Listening exercise is launched.
Now the professional assigns the 3 roles: Speaker; Listener & Observer. The role of the Observer is emphasised, i.e. to observe the dialogue between the speaker and interviewer, and provides observer constructive feedback.
The professional indicates a prompt to be used in the exercise, and which is to mark the start of the actual exercise. The prompt should be expressing the concern or reflection of the speaker related to the issue, problem or challenge to be addressed in the exercise. An example can be “Lately I have been thinking about how I handle difficult/emotional situations” or “I am concerned about the problems young people, like me, face to find a job” (the wording depends on the topic to be treated.
The Listener then listens to what the Speaker is expressing, and after the Speaker has shared his/her initial thoughts, the Listener remains quiet and uses a pause. If this pause does not prompt the Speaker to add on more detail or explanations to the initial thoughts, the Listener uses verbal paraphrasing on what the Speaker has said, and then pauses again.
If the Speaker still does not continue to express their thoughts the Listener should use an open question (embedding verbal paraphrasing in the question), and then pauses again. The listener should be instructed that pauses should not last forever, but no time limit is set for them.
During the full exercise the Listener should use non-verbal paraphrasing during the times the Speaker is talking.
The exercise goes on for about 90 to 120 seconds.
The Observer records the following items:
- The pauses, i.e. describes the moment the pause took place (i.e. after mere silence on the side of the Listener, paraphrasing or open question) and how long it lasted.
- The reaction of the Speaker to the verbal paraphrasing, both in their verbal as non-verbal expressions.
- The non-verbal paraphrasing of the Listener.
The roles are then turned around so that each of the 3 participants has the opportunity to practice all 3 roles.
Final step / Conclusion:
(MANDATORY to explain what to do in order to conclude the exercise)
After the 3 rounds the participants are asked to relate their experience in the activity. The following questions can be used to prompt their replies:
- Pauses: What about the average time Listeners waited? What was the reaction of the Speaker when the Listener used a pause? What do you think is the purpose of the pause?
- Paraphrasing (verbal and non-verbal): What strategies did you use to help paraphrase the content?; How did your Listener show his/her interest and attention as you were speaking?; How did the Listener show his/her non-verbal paraphrasing?; What do you want to take-away about paraphrasing?
- How was it for the Listener/Speaker/Observer to do this exercise?
- What happened when changing roles, and how did your experience in the former role (in the second and third round of the exercise) influenced your behaviour and interaction?
Debrief
- How was it for the Listener/Speaker/Observer to do this exercise? If the professional took the observer role, he/she should express how it was for them as well, after the participants have answered these questions.
- What happened when changing roles, and how did your experience in the former role (in the second and third round of the exercise) influenced your behaviour and interaction? Here in case the professional acted as observer, only the participants answer this question and the observation on the changing roles by the professional in their roles as observer is addressed in the professionals final remarks.
- What did you learn from this activity?
- How could empathic learning help you in your life/profession?
The professional then finalises by summarising the main conclusions and “take-aways” based upon his/her own observations.
Specific materials
Tips and Tricks
● Use videos and images to show actually what you are conveying, e.g. with short video-clips on the specific issue you want to highlight. If there is time, a good practice could be to after the exercise and analysis show a clip and ask the participants to highlight the errors made by the Listener, what works well here is to adapt the clip to the target groups, e.g. a movie which you know relates to them, or an animated video. This can reinforce the take-aways and end the session with a more game-type activity.
● Make sure not only to focus on the 3 ingredients which are the main focus of the exercise but in your conclusions and final remarks highlight the conclusions with regards to all the aspects of empathic listening as mentioned in the preparation of the exercise.
On-line version
Bibliography - Sitography
https://www.healthline.com/health/empathic-listening
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w13LC6DLMn8
Empathic Listening: Empowering Individuals as Leaders. Author: Anna Christine Petersen. The Journal of Student Leadership. 2019
Listening Well: The Art of Empathic Understanding. Author: William R. Miller. Wipf and Stock Publishers, 2018
eccay-curriculum-en.pdf